Our operations will be closed Memorial Day, Monday, May 25. We will return voice messages and emails on Tuesday, May 26, however, you are still able to report payroll or pay your bill on our website. Please note our physical locations will continue to remain closed until further notice.

For updates and policyholder assistance options click here

File a Claim Out of State

Claims Reporting under CompSource Mutual’s Other States’ Coverage Program

All claims under CompSource Mutual’s Other States’ Coverage policies will be handled by a PMA Insurance Group representative with the same quality service you have learned to expect from CompSource Mutual.

Use one of the following methods to file a first notice of injury:


  • Log on to PMA Insurance Group’s website
  • Click on “Report a Claim”
  • Use the following to log in:
    • Username: Last seven digits of PMA policy number
    • Password: newclaim

Phone: (866) 626-3041

Fax: (866) 329-2721

If you have questions at any time during the claims process, call (888) 476-2669 to reach a PMA representative.